It is not impossible that it should fall to the lot of this work, in its poverty and in the darkness of this time, to bring light into one brain or another–but, of course, it is not likely.
My mission to the liberals, which may not have been an entire failure, has come to an end. With the election of Barack Obama, we have reached the limit of what’s possible in our sophisticated post-popular world. Between the Mitch McConnell right and the Chuck Schumer left, our President has found the vital Arlen Specter center.
The mission began began in the dark days of 2002, when Bush had 80% support and the big names in the blogosphere were Ann Coulter, Andy Sullivan, Mickey Kaus, and the inimitable Instapundit. Bush’s intentions were evident from the beginning, at least to me, and for three years he would have a free hand. The Democrats obviously needed help at that time, and I did what I could to comfort them, cheer them up, and convince them to oppose Bush out loud and in public. Gradually, as the international order and global economy collapsed into ruins, the political situation improved, and one by one the liberal hawks slunk back to the world of sanity. Finally in 2006 the Democrats gained control of Congress*, and then last year they won the Presidency.
During all those years I placed myself on the far left of the Democratic Party, either providing them with someone to be less extreme than, or tactfully trying to pull them a little further in my direction. Only seldom did I tell people go fuck themselves. But the tactfulness part finally became wearing, as did the endless toothpulling arguments required, and now I’m laying down my weary load.
Hoping for a popular left movement is like waiting for King Arthur to return in glory. It has been shown by Richard Hofstadter and others that popular movements are always fascist or Communist, and the Democrats have gotten the message. In order to protect us against extremism, they have bravely volunteered to be attacked as Communists themselves, in lieu of the now-extinct real Communists — without, however, relaxing their own anti-Communist vigilance.
The Left is in power, and I am no longer needed. I will return to my customary irresponsibility, and cheerfully curse the darkness to the end of my days.
*By counting the members of the two parties in the two Houses of Congress in 2007, this can be shown to be true.
February 12, 2009 at 4:15 pm
Dude, a laugh (and possibly a sneer) is always more fun. Looking at the places you troll in your link list, they aren’t bad places, as long as you know what you want from them — I’m currently filling the comment box at Crooked Timber with romantic comedy fanfic based on philosophical thought experiments, which is like the perfect subgenre — but politically, they never learn anything. They are surrounded with people who think like them and they will never ever think differently. Look at what they’re doing with Obama. I mean, you might have thought that they would actually generalize the lessons of the Bush years to someone other than Bush, but no. I wonder how long it will take DeLong to rationalize away the uncomfortable fact that all the neoliberals that he said were such great people as Obama was hiring them for his economic team turned out to have no trouble carrying out the same policies as Bush had?
I always laugh when one of them says something disparaging about Kos commenters or something like that, which they do pretty regularly. I mean, you want an actually popular left? Then guess what: most of the people in it aren’t going to be all that hip or sophisticated. They’ve taken the form of blogging that they like and valorized it into being the kind of politics that they like. The “popular left”, if online, is going to be like Atrios’ comment box — and people will disparage that and never notice that Duncan Black seems to have been actually right about everything.
So, yeah, irresponsibility. You can’t wait to be irresponsible, because things may never get better. So I’m back to fanfic.
February 12, 2009 at 4:41 pm
I was a daily reader of Bartcop for a long time. He was a Hillary loyalist and he’s pretty hawkish, which made it sticky after a point, but I thought he had the perfect mix for communicating with average, non-college people who hate Republicans. From time to time I used to link to him or recommend him, but I knew it was hopeless.
The college / non-college divide, exacerbated by the college prestige hierarchy, really trumps race, gender, sexual orientation and religion in a lot of circumstances (not all).
Right about Atrios and Kos, obviously. I guess that being verbal and snarky as I am has sucked me into thinking other verbal snarky people agree with me more than they do.
February 12, 2009 at 5:36 pm
Very sarcastic post there, Jim.
February 12, 2009 at 9:57 pm
A mainstream liberal pundit has been inspired by your snark, so I can confirm that your efforts have not been in vain.
Fare thee well! We on the Near Left will miss your wisdom and guidance. Best of luck in your future endeavors, which I assume will involve explosives and/or hallucinogens.
February 13, 2009 at 5:15 am
It’s funny how different parts of the elephant look to different blind men. I had lunch with a colleague who does environmental law. While I was lamenting about ‘that’s not change that’s more of the same’ in the defense/intelligence sector, he was going on about the ‘ding dong the witch is dead’ attitude in the regulatory agencies. The difference, I think today, is in the nature of the permanent staffs. Folks I deal with believe in the former Admin’s mission, a natural orientation for those who’ve self-selected into defense/intelligence. Folks in his area were held down by appointees who didn’t believe in the agency mission.
February 13, 2009 at 2:27 pm
Here’s Hillary arriving at State, being greeted with flowers and sweets, I think. Some folks seem to be happy about regime change.
February 13, 2009 at 5:27 pm
Can’t seem to comment as “politicalfootball” on wordpress sites any more for some reason, but as a spokesman for the Near Left, I wanted to thank Emerson for his service and wish him well in his future endeavors, which I assume will involve explosives and hallucinogens.
As evidence of Emerson’s lasting influence on liberalism, I submit this from Yglesias, which employs a rhetorical device that was obviously lifted from Emerson.
Also note that even the liberal New Republic seems to have learned something from Emerson, as this New Republic link (also via Yglesias) demonstrates.
And for CharleyCarp, I’ll point out that Hillary was greeted with flowers and sweets when she arrived at the State Department. It’s true: Not everyone is as grumpy as Emerson about regime change.
February 14, 2009 at 2:20 am
I appear to have been blackballed on my work computer by the wordpress anti-spam thing, but as a spokesman for the Near Left, I wanted to thank Emerson for his service and wish him well in his future endeavors, which I assume will involve explosives and hallucinogens.
As evidence of Emerson’s lasting influence on liberalism, I submit this from prominent liberal thinker Yglesias, who employs a rhetorical device that was obviously lifted from Emerson.
Also note that even the liberal New Republic seems to have learned something from Emerson, as this New Republic link (also via Yglesias) demonstrates.
And for CharleyCarp, I’ll point out that Hillary was greeted with flowers and sweets when she arrived at the State Department. Not everyone is as grumpy as Emerson about regime change.
February 17, 2009 at 6:32 pm
I don’t know if moving the Overton window at Unfogged is something you’d think of as productive, but you certainly did. (With mcmanus’s capable help in making it clear what actual trolling looked like.)
February 17, 2009 at 6:41 pm
I have defiantly moved more to the left because of Emerson’s comments. I do have to admit that I started in a stupid place to begin with as an iraq war supporter.
February 18, 2009 at 10:03 pm
I have just deleted all posts, mine and his, referring to PF’s problems with WordPress,
February 19, 2009 at 1:46 pm
And with help from a nice guy at akismet support, I appear to be back in business. Thanks for your efforts on my behalf.